Honestly, if you've seen The Vampire Diaries, The Originals and Legacies - you've won me over already.
If the lobbies aren't looking too good, there's always Netflix... I'm up for a binge-spree any-time.
I'm a designer too, give me some ideas! ^-^
Love FPS games but story-mode games will always have my heart. If you've got any 2-player ones in mind, that'll be even better.